Blueprints, land surveys, membership directories, membership files, photographs, published materials, letters, church programs and directories, sheet music, church newsletters, photograph negatives, photograph slides, training manuals, scrapbooks, CDs, floppy discs, and other materials pertaining to the history and operations of the First Baptist Church Carrollton.

The bulk of the materials in this collection date later than the 1960s, but there are some published materials dating to 1902. While the church was founded in 1847, there are no materials dating to that time due to a fire that destroyed the Carroll County Courthouse in 1928 and with it the church records that were stored there. It is possible that the Church still retains meeting minutes for the early church, but those were not gifted to the University of West Georgia.

One of the strongest features of the First Baptist Church Carrollton records are those related to the church's membership as these include directories; member files containing newspaper clippings, photographs, and other public records; and an extensive number of photograph albums documenting church events and mission trips. These records document the Baptist presence in this region of Georgia.